Best Earl Grey Tea Brand For The Money? [Updated 2018]

Traditioanlly speaking, Earl Grey is made from a black tea blend including oil of bergamot. Its roots in England go back hundreds of years, and is believed to be named after Charles Grey, 2nd Earl Grey, this fellow right here who looks like he’s reaching into his coat for a pistol:

image via wikipedia

Hopefully he’s just reaching for a flask of some hot tea.

In any case, there are conflicting origin stories of this tea, with one saying that the Earl received the blend as a gift from somebody from China who was grateful to him for saving their son. Jacksons of Piccadilly, a teahouse dating back to 1815, claim themselves as the origin of this blend of tea.

Regardless of where it came from, it’s here now – and that’s what matters, right? So, take a sip of some of the teas we recommend on this page.

Here’s a look at some of the BEST sellers…

SaleBestseller No. 1
Twinings of London Earl Grey Black Tea Bags, 100 Count
547 Reviews
Twinings of London Earl Grey Black Tea Bags, 100 Count
  • FRESH FLAVOR: One box of 100 Earl Grey tea bags. Brighten up your day with the...
  • ONLY THE FINEST QUALITY: Our expert blenders source only the finest leaves...
  • EARL GREY TEA: Fresh, fragrant and flavored with distinctive notes of citrus and...
  • RICH HISTORY: In 1706 Thomas Twining began selling fine tea from an English...
SaleBestseller No. 2
Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme, Black Tea, 20 Sachets
2,068 Reviews
Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme, Black Tea, 20 Sachets
  • Earl Grey Supreme uses teas along with the addition of Silver Tips
  • Has lemony flavors.
SaleBestseller No. 3
Bigelow Earl Grey Tea Bags 20-Count Boxes (Pack of 6) Caffeinated Individual Black Tea Bags, for Hot Tea or Iced Tea, Drink Plain or Sweetened with Honey or Sugar
2,278 Reviews
Bigelow Earl Grey Tea Bags 20-Count Boxes (Pack of 6) Caffeinated Individual Black Tea Bags, for Hot Tea or Iced Tea, Drink Plain or Sweetened with Honey or Sugar
  • KING OF EARLS: Not all Earl Grey teas are created equal. oUR Earl Grey Tea...
  • INDIVIDUALLY WRAPPED: Bigelow tea always come individually wrapped in foil...
  • TRY EVERY FLAVOR: There's a Bigelow Tea for every mood and every time of day....
  • AMERICAN MADE TEA: In 1945 Ruth Bigelow created our first tea, Constant Comment,...

The Grey family themselves say the blend was created in order to offset the taste of lime in the local water supply.

Wherever it started, it has become one of the most popular tea blends out there. It’s a very neutral and enjoyable taste, with the bergamot adding a “little something” to the regular tea leaves.

More recently, you’ll find it made from different types of tea, including oolong or even green tea.

Finding The Best Earl Grey Tea Brand in 2018:

Beat earl grey tea brand

Taste is entirely subjective, but we’ve still put together this list of some of the best Earl Grey blends out there. Before we continue, let’s try to quantify what “best” even means. For the purposes of this list, it’s a combination of things, from how well most people enjoy the tea (by aggregating review scores from across the web), how accessible it is, and in this case, whether it’s worth the money or not for the average tea consumer. You might find a really nice blend that’s VERY expensive, but if most people won’t really notice the difference or appreciate it, it won’t necessarily earn the top spot since we’re taking value into consideration here.

These are all excellent teas, that are relatively reasonable priced (Some are more affordable than others, but they’re all within reach for somebody who is looking to invest in some new teas for their collection.) If you really want to put your tea storage area to the test, you could try a few of these. Would you enjoy brewing several Earl Grey tea brands at once, and then comparing them?

1. TOP PICK FOR BEST EARL GREY TEA: Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme

Sale
Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme, Black Tea, 20 Sachets
2,068 Reviews
Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme, Black Tea, 20 Sachets
  • Earl Grey Supreme uses teas along with the addition of Silver Tips
  • Has lemony flavors.

Let’s cut right to the chase and end the suspense, here’s our overall pick. The Supreme blend by Harney & Sons contains four different teas, silver tips, and bergamot. All things considered, if you’re looking for an Earl Grey tea brand you can rely on, this is a solid pick.

It lands on the pricier end of the scale when you break down the prize per ounce of tea, so if you’re very budget conscious you might want to try the next one, or something else from this list, but if you don’t mind spending a little bit more – this is a good one to add to your cart.

2. Taylors of Harrogate Earl Grey Tea

Taylors of Harrogate Earl Grey Loose Leaf, 4.41 Ounce Tin
4,094 Reviews
Taylors of Harrogate Earl Grey Loose Leaf, 4.41 Ounce Tin
  • The elegant fragrance of the bergamot fruit gives Earl Grey its famous flavour....
  • Made with a blend of fine black China teas and oil of bergamot
  • High in antioxidants; loose tea lets you brew the perfect cup
  • Full-bodied, distinctive flavor and aroma; tea comes in an elegant and reusable...

Taylor’s of Harrogate is a staple in many homes, it’s a solid tea, very reasonable, very accessible. Now, some would argue it’s not the 2nd best Earl Grey Tea in the entire world, and we’d likely have to agree, but once again, this list is taking more into account than just that. With the option to go for loose leaf or bagged, there’s something for everyone.

Here’s some information from the manufacturer themselves: “Said to be from a secret recipe given to Earl Grey by a Chinese Mandarin in 1830, Earl Grey tea has a distinct flavor and aroma. A blend of fine black China teas and the natural oil of bergamot, this is a full-bodied, richly-flavored treat any time of the day.”

3. Mighty Leaf Organic Earl Grey Tea Pouches

Mighty Leaf Black Tea, Organic Earl Grey, 15 Pouches (Pack of 3) Package May Vary
161 Reviews
Mighty Leaf Black Tea, Organic Earl Grey, 15 Pouches (Pack of 3) Package May Vary
  • Delicious, artisan tea
  • Whole leaf pouches bring out the full flavor
  • Pairs well with a nice tea biscuit
  • Tastes great on its own or sweetened up with milk and sugar

This is a nice tea, and it brings you the best of both worlds when it comes to loose leaf tea vs bagged. These little pouches contain loose leaf leaf, rather than tea bags where the tea has often been ground a lot finer and is sometimes of lower quality. This Earl Grey brand is nice because they bring you the convenience of bagged tea, with the quality of loose. It’s very well reviewed, very reasonable priced, very nice tea that has earned a spot on this list.

4. Tippy Organic Earl Grey by Golden Moon Tea

Sale
Golden Moon Tea - Tippy Earl Grey Loose Leaf Tea | Fresh All Natural Revitalizing Flavor & Aroma | Real Italian Bergamot Peels & Extract | 96 Servings of Earl Grey Organic English Style Tea
371 Reviews
Golden Moon Tea - Tippy Earl Grey Loose Leaf Tea | Fresh All Natural Revitalizing Flavor & Aroma | Real Italian Bergamot Peels & Extract | 96 Servings of Earl Grey Organic English Style Tea
  • THE PERFECT CUPPA EARL GREY: Relax, Refresh, and Revitalize with Golden Moon's...
  • REAL ITALIAN BERGAMOT: All natural 100% Italian Bergamot extract provides a...
  • SUPERIOR 3 TEA BLEND: Unlike other brands that usually rely on just one low...
  • USDA ORGANIC & NON GMO: All our teas are USDA organic which means they're free...

By the sounds of it, putting together this blend was a real labor of love.  They visited dozens of tea houses in London to make sure they were getting things just right, and have sourced their bergamot from Southern Italy, using the oils from the peel for a fresh taste rather than any alternative flavorings. The goal was to make an Earl Grey that could stand up to scrutiny and make Brits proud, and it’s also quite reasonable priced at pennies per serving. We’ll call that mission: accomplished.

5. WILDCARD: Have your say!

image: thednetworks.com

We’re going to leave this last option open as a bit of a ‘wild card’ so that our readers can submit their own suggestions of their favorite Earl Greys. Do you have a favorite Earl Grey Tea brand? Here’s your chance to give them a shout out. If you have your own brand that you sell, let us know what sets it apart and makes it one of the best options for the money. Also, if there’s any interest, we can also do a run down of more exclusive, higher-end, ’boutique’ Earl Greys for those who aren’t really worried about the price.

In any case, you can get in touch with us on Twitter to let us know your choice for the best Earl Grey, and we’ll take every answer into consideration while we finalize this list.

Last update on 2018-11-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API